Is peanut butter healthy? The answer may be complicated. It’s a simple spread made from crushed legumes, so it seems like it should be healthy. But it offers a mixed blessing. It offers a great blend of nutrients, but it can also be high in fat and calories.

In a few cases, it can even cause lethal allergic reactions. Like any food, it can be dangerous when it is consumed in the wrong way, and it’s much more dangerous for some people than it is for others.

is peanut butter healthy

What Is Peanut Butter?

Peanut butter looks simple, but looks can be deceiving. Peanuts make its core ingredient, and you can make peanut butter that does not include anything else. But most brands include a few other components.

Sugar is the most common additive. Cane sugar is the most common, but some companies do prefer to use other sugary sweeteners, such as palm sugar. The sugar makes the peanut butter much more appealing to customers with a sweet tooth, but it also makes it less healthy. Since most brands include sugar, the sugarless peanut butters tend to taste a little bit strange to people who aren’t used to them.

Most peanut butters also include some preservatives. Many of them are harmless. But their precise health impact varies from one preservative to the next. Some also include emulsifiers to stop the peanut oil from separating out of the mix. Those that don’t include one need to be stirred before consumption.

Items That Contain Peanut Butter

Plenty of people eat peanut butter on its own, but it also shows up as an ingredient in plenty of other foods.

  • Cookies often include peanut butter. Peanut cookies tend to have it as a main ingredient. But it’s also a minor component in many other recipes.
  • Candy companies love to use peanut butter as a flavoring agent. Almost all of the candies that include it are clearly labeled as peanut products.
  • Peanut butter sandwiches make up probably the most famous use for the food.
  • Oatmeal blends sometimes include peanut butter, usually in a small quantity as a flavoring tool rather than as a main ingredient.
  • Peanut butter shows up in a lot of simple appetizers, often paired with a mild vegetable or a salty snack food. Some are sold as prepared products, but most people make their own.

The Dangers of Peanut Butter

Is peanut butter healthy for everyone? The answer is a clear no, and allergies are to blame. Peanut allergies are among the most common. they can lead to fatal cases of anaphylaxis in a minority of cases. Other people suffer from milder symptoms, like general discomfort and difficulty breathing. The problem is most common in children, although about a fifth of them grow out of it over time. It’s important to note that while people who are allergic to tree nuts are not necessarily allergic to peanuts, that is often the case. When in doubt, try peanut butter in a small quantity to minimize the risk.

Is peanut butter healthy, based on its nutritional profile? There are some nutritional risk factors. The exact nutritional profile will vary based on the brand, but all of them are fairly high in calories and fat. That isn’t a problem if you eat it in moderation. However, it’s easy to overeat because it packs a huge number of calories into a small volume. Since excessive eating and weight gain are linked to early death, heart disease, and a variety of other medical problems, eating too much peanut butter can lead to serious issues.

peanuts in bowl

Are There Benefits of Peanut Butter?

On the other hand, peanut butter also has some significant nutritional benefits. Peanuts are actually nuts, so they are very high in protein. That makes peanut butter one of the most useful foods for people who do not consume meat. It’s also fairly high in most of the important minerals and fiber, which are vital for maintaining good health.

Is peanut butter healthy for the environment? It can be. Peanut farming is also excellent for the soil. Peanuts can perform nitrogen fixation for the soil. That process allows them to act as a natural fertilizer as they grow. It’s a vital tool for many organic farmers who use it as an alternative to artificial fertilizers, which are made from very limited resources. Peanut shells can also be broken down to serve as compost, so even the waste can help the soil.

Spreading the Butter

On the balance of evidence, is peanut butter healthy or not? It certainly can be healthy, but only if you eat it in moderation. If you eat it in excess, or if you have an allergy, it can lead to health problems. However, once you stay responsible, it can be a great addition to your diet.

If you know of any good ways to use a healthy amount of peanut butter, be sure to share them in the comment section so other readers can put that knowledge to good use in their own kitchens.

Images from